Back to all posts

Why Unfinished Business Keeps Players Hooked

An incomplete collection, a progress map, and the Zeigarnik effect as a game design tool.

While playing LD games, I started wondering why I finish some of them and abandon others. Usually, I would play for 5-10 minutes, get a feel for the game’s idea, jot down a few points for my review, and drop it. Only a handful of games held my attention all the way to the end.

So I started analyzing what those games had in common. I concluded that it was a sense of unfinished business, as if I had only a little way left to go and quitting would be a shame.

For example, one game shows you an incomplete collection right at the start. There is a cabinet where every item is shown as a black silhouette. As you play, you collect the items and fill out the collection. At some point, you are ready to drop the game, but then you notice that the cabinet is around 70 percent complete. Quitting feels like a waste. You want to finish what you started.

Another common trick is to show the player a progress map from time to time. In most games, you have no idea how much content is still ahead. So once you feel that you have seen enough, nothing stops you from dropping the game. But when you are constantly reminded how far you have left to the finish line, that sense of unfinished business kicks in. It feels wrong to quit when there is so little left to do.

Psychology even has a name for this feeling: the Zeigarnik effect. While sitting in a cafe one day, psychologist Bluma Zeigarnik noticed that waiters remembered unpaid orders extremely well but forgot paid ones almost immediately. She decided to test the phenomenon through various experiments. For example, she gave people tasks to solve: one group was allowed to finish, while the other was interrupted before they could. As it turned out, the group that was not allowed to finish remembered the tasks better.

Anyway, I should try using this effect in the next jam and see how many players finish the game.