Back to all posts

Brutal Criticism Is the Price of a Fresh Perspective

What I realized when, three months later, I found a streamer's harsh review of my first game jam game.

After my first game jam, I sent the game to a streamer for review. His review queue was around three months long, though, so I promptly forgot about it. I remembered recently and, after a serious amount of digging, finally found the segment where he reviewed my bugs.

Well, what can I say? If I had seen that review back then, I would have been seriously pissed off. The guy reviews games very critically, as if they were full Steam releases. He makes no allowances for the fact that this was a game jam entry and my first attempt at making a game.

I prefer the Ludum Dare approach, where commenters look for what a game did well. The creators already know perfectly well that their game is infinitely far from commercial success on Steam.

Anyway, here were his criticisms:

  • The background is too busy. I completely agree: our eyes are drawn to the amount of detail, so more important objects should be more detailed than less important ones. It is wrong for the bugs to have less detail than the background.
  • There is no risk/reward element. Also a fair point: you cannot lose the game.
  • There is no progression. I wanted to add it, but I simply ran out of time.
  • The magnifying glass could have been cut entirely. I agree with this one too: it took a huge amount of time because it was technically difficult to implement, yet it adds very little to the game.

The chat’s reaction was a nice bonus. The game sparked a pretty lively discussion, and there were some good comments. It did earn a high humor score for a reason, after all.

Overall, putting a game out in public is always uncomfortable. Praise from people close to you feels good, but it does not move you forward. That awkward, prickly criticism that makes you want to shut down is the price you pay for a fresh perspective. It is unpleasant and it stings, but it is the only way to see your work not through your own eyes, full of love and excuses, but through someone else’s: cold and impartial. You have to learn to pay that price, even if your first reaction will always be, “The fuck did you just say, asshole?” :)

Watch the review on YouTube.